Microbiology Procedure
  Home  Link to us  Resources  Site map  Search  Language

Index >>Immunity >> Comparison of Live Vaccines and Killed Vaccines

Comparison of Live Vaccines and Killed Vaccines

Comparison of Lived Vaccines and Killed Vaccines

Formaldehyde and β-propiolactone are usually used for inactivation of virus. These agents inactivate viral nucleic acid function. Generally, a small fraction of the population (approx. 1,000,000,000 particles make one dose) is inactivated far more slowly than the majority, so that the whole virus population has to be kept in contact with the inactivating agent for much longer period.

There is a danger of destruction of immunogenicity during this period. Live vaccines present no such problems. Jonas Salk faced this type of problems when he presented first polio virus vaccine (killed) in 1953 to the public. Albert Sabin in 1957 could produce successful live vaccine for polio.

A killed vaccine is injected twice to build up a sufficient immune response, since they are not able to multiply. Live vaccines may multiply and reach at places where infectious virus is present. Live vaccines are cheap to produce compared with killed vaccines. The killed vaccines are needed more in quantity. In multiple vaccination, killed vaccines are preferred our live ones.

It is possible to immunize with a vaccine cocktail, that minimizes the number of. injections and inconvenience. Results are satisfactory with multiple killed vaccines. Live vaccines may have problems due to mutual interference in multiplication possibly as a result of the induction of interferon. However, a triple live vaccine of measles, mumps and rubella viruses has been successfully used

Home | Site map | Submit Article | Resources | Search